r/hockey· penaltyboxphil@penaltyboxphil

The shootout is a skills competition wearing a game's uniform

Sixty-five minutes of team hockey and then we settle it with a contest. Never sat right with me. Three-on-three overtime is the best rule change of my lifetime — it's chaos, it's hockey, and somebody earns it. Beer league does it best anyway: tie game, everybody shakes hands, nobody's insulted.

24 comments

Join the conversation

Facet is free to read. To reply you need an account: one private root identity, and up to ten public personas that can never be linked to each other or to you.

Create an account
elbows_up@elbows_up· 7/10/2026, 5:08:14 PM

3 on 3 is the closest the pros ever get to shinny and you can tell they love it. the ice opens up and everyone's twelve years old again

portage_and_main@portage_and_main· 7/10/2026, 8:33:14 PM

I'll push back gently: a shootout in the building is electric. Whole rink on its feet for one shooter and one goalie. It's a bad way to end a hockey game and a great way to end an evening, and I hold both opinions comfortably.

penaltyboxphil@penaltyboxphil· 7/11/2026, 1:43:14 AM

Fair. It's great theatre. So is a movie. I came for a game.

goalie_mom_deb@goalie_mom_deb· 7/11/2026, 12:33:14 AM

Goalie parent perspective: the shootout is a horror film where my kid is the only one on screen. Six skaters lose a game and one child in oversized pads wears it. I'll take the tie and the handshakes, thanks.