second_paycheque@second_paychequeSuggested a gift draw to my family instead of everyone buying for everyone. The group chat is taking it about how you'd expect.
Every December my family does the thing where all the adults buy something for all the other adults, which mostly means a pile of candles and gift cards changing hands. During my payoff years it was the most stressful line in the whole budget, and I'm not doing that again now that I'm finally ahead. So in September, while nobody's feeling festive or emotional yet, I floated a draw. Everyone picks one name, there's a spending cap, and the kids still get something from everyone. My mum loved it. One cousin said it 'takes the magic out.' A couple of people have left it on read, which I'm choosing to take as a yes. Anyone made this switch? How did you bring the holdouts around without becoming the family Grinch?
Join the conversation
Facet is free to read. To reply you need an account: one private root identity, and up to ten public personas that can never be linked to each other or to you.
Create an account
brasstacks_barb@brasstacks_barb· 9/24/2026, 11:46:53 PMRetired teacher, survivor of many staff-room gift exchanges. Pitch it as more fun, not less spending. Nobody votes for budget cuts. Everybody votes for a surprise. Add one playful rule, something handmade or something local under the cap, and it stops being a cutback and becomes a game.
loonie_tunes@loonie_tunes· 9/25/2026, 12:51:53 AMMy friend group switched to a draw and the person who said it would ruin everything was the one sending out the name-draw reminders the very next year. People enjoy picking one thoughtful thing far more than grabbing a pile of panic candles.
second_paycheque@second_paycheque· 9/25/2026, 1:36:53 AMThat's the arc I'm counting on. This cousin is extremely an organizer, so there's hope.
wanderlust_on_layaway@wanderlust_on_layaway· 9/25/2026, 3:26:53 AMHonest question: how are you handling the cap for people with a lot less? A number that's comfortable for some people in a family can still be a real stretch for others.
second_paycheque@second_paycheque· 9/25/2026, 4:21:53 AMThat's why I pitched a low cap on purpose. I remember being the one who couldn't afford it and pretending I could. The cap should fit the tightest budget in the room, not the average one.
thrifted_thunder@thrifted_thunder· 9/25/2026, 5:21:53 AMAnd make secondhand officially allowed. A great used book or a thrifted cast iron pan beats a new gift card at twice the price, every time.
SixStringBudget@sixstringbudget· 9/25/2026, 7:56:53 AMMild dissent: my wife's family does everyone-for-everyone and it's genuinely the one time of year some of them think about each other. They kept the tradition and added a low cap instead. Same budget relief, slightly more candles.